Magazine: City

Crossing the White Line

Cyclists, motorists struggle to cope with sharing the road

14 Comments

By Kendra R. Chamberlain

Posted Feb 1, 2012
Cyclist commuter Clayton Weeks battles with traffic everyday as he rides down Perkins Rd. He said that cyclists are treated much better today than they were five years ago. (Credit: Adam Pitts)
Flowers and condolences offered at the ghost bike, erected at the scene of the accident that killed Nathaniel Crowson and severely injured another cyclist, is a testament to the shock and sadness within the community regarding the incident. (Credit: Adam Pitts)

Mayor-president Melvin “Kip” Holden was quick to assure both the media and other cyclists in the community that the tragic accident – one cyclist killed, the other in the hospital – that occurred two weeks ago was not an issue of bikes lanes, but instead bad driving.

“A wider roadway would not have necessarily dictated that a biker or pedestrian, or a car, would not have been hit by a person who was intoxicated,” Mayor Holden was quoted in The Advocate, following the incident.

The incident shook the community – not just other cyclists, but runners, joggers, pedestrians, even drivers who commute across town. Everyone felt a sting.

The Mayor’s rhetoric didn’t stop the community – whether riders or drivers – from voicing concern about the roads in Baton Rouge – instead, it served to initiate a dialogue looking to more clearly, and physically, define the relationship between the burgeoning, non-motorist, commuter community, and the rest of the city drivers.

Two wheel transportation

Martin is the founder of the Baton Rouge Advocates for Safe Streets (BRASS), a six-year-old cycling advocacy organization. He is also a commuter, meaning that he has no car. Six years ago, he started BRASS as a way to help a small community of bike riders some recognition on the road. Now, his organization is one of the bigger bike clubs, and hold weekly rides, offers bike maintenance and mechanic services, and is looking to open up a co-op.

The expansion and success of his organization is just as much a testament to his leadership as it is an indication of the growing community of cyclists here in Baton Rouge.

Commuters, as they are called, are not nearly as rare as they once were – though they are still are a small, tight-knit group.

Travis Hans is one active member of the community. He owns the shop Mid City Bikes on Government, and said he uses his bicycle as his preferred method of travel, though he does own a few vehicles.

“I recently was able to get my son in a school in the area, so I no longer have to drive daily,” Hans said. “I drive maybe once or twice a week.”

In light of the recent accident on Perkins Rd., Hans presents a striking image. Standing in his shop, he pointed to a bright green bucket-shaped attachment connected to the handlebars of his bike.

“That’s what he sits in, and we ride around,” Hans said, referring to his two-year-old son.

I asked Hans if he ever felt afraid riding around town on the road with cars.

“It’s definitely dangerous,” he said. “Scary is more relevant.”

(Hans noted that now that he has a son, he tends to take more safe roads than he once did).

To an avid car-driver, that seems like a tough-as-nails stance to take on something as common as commuting.

Hans’ opinion on the matter isn’t all that unique here in Baton Rouge. Not anymore, at least.

Clayton Weeks is another commuter, and not surprisingly, he works at another bicycle shop: Capital City Cyclery, located on Essen Dr.

“I have three or four rear lights on my bike, all the time, day or night,” said Weeks, who travels down Perkins Road twice a day to get to and from his job. “I ride past [the ghost bike] every day.”

Weeks, who also has a car and prefers to ride his bicycle, is very familiar with the perils of sharing the road.

“Crossing traffic is the most dangerous part of the bike – much more dangerous than going with traffic,” he explained. “There’s a lot of variables when I’m making the decisions on what roads to take.”

Weeks said that both safety and efficiency play a role in his decisions when planning routes.

“If there is a side street, it’s the cyclist’s responsibility to take those side streets,” Weeks explained. “For the most part, I try to take those, but going down Perkins, there really is no other feasible route to get [to work].”

The problem, according to Weeks, are the intersections. The side streets are (theoretically) slower in terms of traffic speed. But side streets present their own problems, especially if they are big enough to have lights.

“Typically when I’m riding, I’m riding assertively. I’m riding down Perkins, I’m in the far right lane, and I’m riding with a little bit of speed beneath my belt – I’m not going four miles an hour, I’m trying to go as fast as I can,” Weeks said. “I want to be a part of traffic, I don’t want to be in opposition to traffic. I want everyone to treat me like they would expect a car to react. That way, it’s predictable on both sides of the equation.”

For the most part, motorists do a good job of giving cyclists enough room, and even waiting, if they have to, until the opportunity arises to pass a bike. But sometimes, the relationship isn’t nearly as mutually respectful as it could be.

Sore muscles and growing pains

Incidents like Crowson’s death are tragic and, thankfully, relatively rare. But close calls are pretty common – in fact, Hans told us about one incident that happened over the weekend.

According to Hans, a motorist pulled into a group of cyclists near the intersection of Perkins Rd. and Kenilworth – the same area, Hans noted, that Crowson was killed.

Hans said that the vehicle “bumped into” a cyclist, resulting in a broken mirror on the vehicle.

“When the police showed up, they wanted to ticket the fellow that hit the mirror,” Hans said.

Legally, motorists are required to give bicycle-riders a berth of three feet. Most cyclists we spoke to agreed that some motorists follow the law, and some don’t.

Weeks attributed close calls to naïveté on the part of the drivers.

“It’s out of ignorance,” Weeks said. “Because they don’t ride bikes, they don’t understand that other half of the equation.” The most dangerous situations come when motorists seem to lose patience with cyclists sharing the road – either the motorist will try to pass a cyclist without enough space, or, in more extreme cases, verbally or physically assault the cyclist. But it’s not happening nearly as often as it once was.

“Rarely has it gotten to be so close that I’m worried,” Weeks said. “Every now and again, people will yell at me.”

Hans concurred.

“Ten years ago, you got bottles thrown at you for riding your bicycle through town. Very rarely do I even hear stories of that today.”

The good news, for motorists and cyclists alike, is that we’re all getting more accustomed to having cyclists on the road.

It makes sense that a cyclist would prefer to have his or her own designated lane to ride in. From a driver’s perspective, it makes sense, too. If cyclists had their own lanes, drivers wouldn’t have to worry about passing them. But even Hans said having each busy street have a bike lane is unrealistic.

“That’s not easy,” he said. “Even in the best bicycle cultures in the U.S., they don’t have completely separate bicycle facilities to get across town. No one has that. We do know that as ridership increases, injury to cyclists, per capita, goes down – due to awareness,” Hans said.

An alternative to the bike lane is to paint sharrows on the streets that serve as main veins through the city but don’t have dedicated bike lanes. Sharrows (those arrows painted on some streets with a bicycle icon) are meant to indicate to both cyclists and motorists that the road is designated for both to share – hence the name.

“The sharrows are doing something, because they’re increasing awareness about cyclists,” Hans said.

Car culture mentality

After the accident on Perkins and Quail Run, the Mayor-president’s administration went on the defensive, a move that seemed to indicate the severity of the accident and the severity of the perceived backlash from the community.

Both Mayor Holden and his chief administrator John Carpenter emphasized that the incident was first and foremost the result of drunk driving, not unsafe streets.

The point is well taken. The suspect Joseph Branch, who was arrested on a second-offense DWI, had a blood-alcohol level of 0.307 – just under four times the legal limit.

The cyclist community is well aware of that.

“A bike lane would not have saved [Crowson],” Weeks said.

But for many concerned members of the community, the administration had missed the point.

“To me the point was not that they were on Perkins, but that they had to be on Perkins to get where they were going,” Martin said, adding that BRASS has been working to get bike facilities included in the new road construction projects in the Mayor’s Green Light Plan. Though the city has progressed in leaps and bounds in terms of bikeability in the last few years under the stewardship of Mayor Holden, the cycling community has suffered some setbacks – most recently when Department of Public Works director William Daniel said that bike paths are not a priority.

“I’m not sure that if you poll people in Baton Rouge that the lack of bike paths would come up in the top 20 problems that we need to address,” Daniel was quoted in The Advocate last week.

“It’s not a question of cost so much as a mentality,” Martin said, adding that incidents like Crowson’s can be influential in changing mentality.

“How many people do we need to sacrifice before someone says ‘Ok, ok?’ It helps in the sense that it’s a tragedy, and it makes people say ‘oh my god, why did this happen?’”

Tragedy Struck

Nathaniel Crowson, 30, and Daniel Morris, 31, were traveling on Perkins Rd. near Quail Run Dr. when the two cyclists were struck by a motorist. Crowson died at the scene, while Morris was transported to the hospital and remained under a medically induced coma for multiple days. Supporters have erected a ghost bike memorial at the scene.

How to Help

The community has come together to help support Nathan Crowson’s family and Daniel Morris’ recovery in amazing ways. Mid City Bikes is currently holding a raffle for a Dolan Bike, proceeds going to help the family, while anyone who donates blood in the name of Daniel Morris will help him pay his medical bills. Check out Mid City Bikes, located at 2560 Government Street for more information, or call 225-636-5776.

Comments

Anonymous @ 02/01/2012 01:26 pm

It is a tragedy that the biker was killed, but this is more of a drunk driving issue. However, bike lanes would be nice to have in areas of high bike traffic. Sometimes there aren't three feet to give, when you only have a single lane and there is oncoming traffic. Oh, and 2-4 bikers taking up entire lanes; get on the side of the road. You aren't cars.

Alexander Perlis @ 02/01/2012 02:26 pm

No complaints to adding bike lanes to car-centric roads, certainly better than nothing, but a better use of taxpayer money would be to build small bicycle/pedestrian "connectors" between our many neighborhoods that are cut off from each other by waterways, tracks, or dangerous high-speed or multi-lane roads. Some do exist, for example the Nairn Dr to Ferrett St connector, but we need a lot more, throughout town. That way bicyclists can reach their destination without having to go on car-centric roads in the first place!

zach @ 02/01/2012 03:18 pm

If there aren't 3 feet to give, then don't pass... that's the law. When cyclists take up a whole lane, it is precisely because of people like you who decide to pass even when there isn't enough room to pass safely.

LynnO @ 02/01/2012 03:35 pm

To the anonymous poster above: Bicycles are vehicles just like cars, they have the right to take the lane as much as a car. When there isn't 3 feet to give, you slow down and wait until you do have room to pass, simple. This IS an issue of drunk driving as well as transportation in the city. We are all looking for the many solutions that will help a tragedy like this from happening, like better conditions for bikes, encouraging public transit, and figuring out how to keep people from driving drunk in the first place.

vickib @ 02/01/2012 04:02 pm

I think another issue that I haven't seen getting covered is that if we had an efficient mode of public transportation on top of sidewalks/bike paths it would get a lot of drunk drivers off of the road to begin with. The reason drinking and driving is such a part of our town is that there is no other option but to drive. If everyone could just go out drinking and hop on the bus or walk home maybe the incidence of DWIs would go down. I just think it is something to think about when the vote for CATs dedicated funding comes up in April. We shouldn't have to keep losing our friends to be able to see that we need to make changes.

Randy @ 02/01/2012 04:56 pm

If you are planning on getting drunk out on the town plan on paying for a cab not driving home with one eye covered having battles with multiple lines on the road in your head.

NotBobDole @ 02/01/2012 05:06 pm

If bikes are to share the road, then they need to have a license plate. It doesn't have to be expensive, but it needs to insure they also know the rules of the road.

Stacey @ 02/01/2012 05:24 pm

I agree with the mayor - drunk driving and not road design is at fault for this particular incident. However, he nor anyone else has offered a solution for the drunk driving! Like vickib said, we need funding for significant service increases in public transportation to give drunk drivers an alternative to getting behind the wheel. It's hard for a group of friends going out for an evening to say, "Hey, one of you can't drink because we need a designated driver." No one wants to do that. Baton Rouge is often called a "drinking town with a football problem". We have large portion of the population in bars every night of the week. It's time we, as a city, took some responsibility for allowing that drinking culture to thrive. One way to significantly curtail the problem is to have a useful and city-wide public transit system. In addition to public transit, the DWI laws are almost wholly useless. When we make a drunk pay fees instead of... more
I agree with the mayor - drunk driving and not road design is at fault for this particular incident. However, he nor anyone else has offered a solution for the drunk driving! Like vickib said, we need funding for significant service increases in public transportation to give drunk drivers an alternative to getting behind the wheel. It's hard for a group of friends going out for an evening to say, "Hey, one of you can't drink because we need a designated driver." No one wants to do that. Baton Rouge is often called a "drinking town with a football problem". We have large portion of the population in bars every night of the week. It's time we, as a city, took some responsibility for allowing that drinking culture to thrive. One way to significantly curtail the problem is to have a useful and city-wide public transit system. In addition to public transit, the DWI laws are almost wholly useless. When we make a drunk pay fees instead of getting alcohol treatment, we're daring them to drink and drive again. How do we have 6TH OFFENSE DWIs when we have a 3 DWI limit? It's clear that not enough is being done to prevent the problem from reoccurring. less

Stacey @ 02/01/2012 05:29 pm

Oh, and NotBobDole, the bikers are rarely the ones who do not know the rules, but even if they were always at fault in an accident - THEY ARE PEOPLE ON BIKES WITHOUT A 2-TON METAL SHROUD protecting them. If a car driver gets in an accident at 20mph with another car, they may be dented, but everyone will go home alive. That is absolutely not the case with a cyclist. Bikes are easy to simply because they are smaller. MOTORISTS need to constantly be vigilant for ANY roadway problem, regardless of the behavior of other drivers or cyclists.

Randy @ 02/01/2012 05:47 pm

If the drunk driver is to blame why is he out of jail?

Justin Time @ 02/01/2012 06:02 pm

If the issue here is really just a case of "bad driving" then why in the world was the driver allowed to post bail? He's back out on the streets with 2 DUI's and a vehicular homicide under his belt? And we're safer, how?

Anelian @ 02/01/2012 11:19 pm

@ Anonymous-- OF COURSE there's someone like you already posting here. Typical. LOL THERE ARE MANY OTHER WAYS TO HELP: Danny is still in the hospital and the bills are stacking up. You can donate blood to help, regardless of type, at Our Lady of the Lake amongst other places. Nathan's daughter will have a trust fund set up soon that you can donate too. You can keep up with this with Facebook or Google. ANNNND: Regardless of what any of us think, the fact remains: The stretch of Perkins Road that links two vital sections of the city is unsafe to travel if you are riding a bike, walking, or riding the bus. This then puts drivers in danger. So everyone is in danger. There isn't even a complete sidewalk. And, regardless of what any of us think, EVERYONE has a right to use the road safely.

Heather Brouillette @ 02/02/2012 08:40 pm

Follow up to BobDole's statement: "If [cars] are to share the road, then they need to have a license plate. It doesn't have to be expensive, but it needs to ensure they also know the rules of the road." Consider this. The Louisiana Driver's Guide (see http://tinyurl.com/Louisiana-Driver-s-Guide) explicitly states the following (pp. 52-4): "Bicycles have the same rights to use public roads as automobiles and must follow the same traffic laws as other vehicles." "Many drivers find it hard to know how to react to bicyclists riding in the street. For the safety of both drivers and bicyclists the following precautions should be taken while driving and bicycling." And it provides instructional lists that guide would be licensed motorists on: (1) how to approach and pass bicyclists, (2) how to turn near bicyclists, and (3) how to share the road with bicyclists in hazardous conditions. Realize that the vast majority of us... more
Follow up to BobDole's statement: "If [cars] are to share the road, then they need to have a license plate. It doesn't have to be expensive, but it needs to ensure they also know the rules of the road." Consider this. The Louisiana Driver's Guide (see http://tinyurl.com/Louisiana-Driver-s-Guide) explicitly states the following (pp. 52-4): "Bicycles have the same rights to use public roads as automobiles and must follow the same traffic laws as other vehicles." "Many drivers find it hard to know how to react to bicyclists riding in the street. For the safety of both drivers and bicyclists the following precautions should be taken while driving and bicycling." And it provides instructional lists that guide would be licensed motorists on: (1) how to approach and pass bicyclists, (2) how to turn near bicyclists, and (3) how to share the road with bicyclists in hazardous conditions. Realize that the vast majority of us [cyclists] you see on the road are also licensed drivers. We are well aware of our rights and responsibilities as operators of both types of vehicles. I ride like I drive. Defensively. I stop at red lights and even stop signs at active intersections, and of course I yield to pedestrians. Okay, so I understand and actively follow the rules, but this does not shield me from irresponsible motorists who are either ignorant or defiant of what constitutes safe and legal driving behaviors. To add a tag to a bicycle will not nullify the fact that motorists who do not also use bicycles as a form of transportation cannot be trusted to drive lawfully when encountering a cyclist traveling within the same lane of traffic. Everyday, cyclists in our community are forced to utilize some portion of a car-centric road because our city lacks both connectors and an efficient public transit system. It is is unfortunate that BR went to the trouble to equip CATS buses with bicycle racks. If only the bus system worked then cyclists could on many occasions bypass large portions of car-centric streets like Perkins, Bluebonnet, and Essen. less

Hallie @ 02/03/2012 11:12 am

Kendra: Thanks for the story. Ride on and ride safely!

Add your voice







Avatars are powered by Gravatar

Get on the list!

Exclusive DIG Invites and giveaways and weekend Gameplan sent to your inbox every week.

Reader Poll

Should LSU have to release the names of candidates for president of the university system?



CrowdSavings.com Deal of the Day

Most Commented

Generation Tweet

POSTED: Feb 2 | 957 COMMENTS

Shush No More

POSTED: May 25 | 220 COMMENTS

Ditch the Suit, Telecommute

POSTED: Dec 7 | 91 COMMENTS

Cannabis Non Grata

POSTED: Apr 18 | 81 COMMENTS

Asinine Astrology

POSTED: Sep 28 | 79 COMMENTS

Tigers Take a Stand

POSTED: Apr 6 | 76 COMMENTS

The Rocking Chair Catcher

POSTED: Apr 11 | 70 COMMENTS

Bone Thugs-N-History

POSTED: Mar 21 | 57 COMMENTS

City Favorites for the Newcomer

POSTED: Aug 15 | 56 COMMENTS

Resistance is Futile

POSTED: Apr 18 | 54 COMMENTS

Monday Morning Twister

POSTED: Dec 12 | 1 COMMENTS

A Month Left to Live

POSTED: Nov 21 | 1 COMMENTS

A Space for Art

POSTED: Nov 7 | 1 COMMENTS

Big Money

POSTED: Nov 21 | 1 COMMENTS

Hello, Baton Rouge

POSTED: Nov 21 | 1 COMMENTS

Drive-by Poetry on I-49

POSTED: Nov 7 | 1 COMMENTS

Birds Are Back in Town

POSTED: Nov 28 | 1 COMMENTS

Opening Credits

POSTED: Nov 14 | 1 COMMENTS

Bland. James Bland.

POSTED: Nov 14 | 1 COMMENTS

Dollar Burgers

POSTED: Nov 28 | 1 COMMENTS